Independent Review & Peer Review

Independent review and peer review play a critical role in projects where structural performance, safety, and accountability are of high consequence. These services provide an additional layer of technical scrutiny, helping ensure that key assumptions, analytical approaches, and design decisions are sound and defensible.

Scope of Review

Our independent review services include:

  • Third-party review of structural design and analysis
  • Evaluation of seismic assessment and retrofit studies
  • Review of analytical models, assumptions, and governing response mechanisms
  • Verification of compliance with applicable codes and performance objectives
  • Assessment of constructability and implementation risks

Reviews may be carried out at different stages of a project, from early concept development to final design and construction documentation.

Independent reviews are conducted with technical independence and professional rigor. The focus is not on re-performing calculations mechanically, but on examining whether the adopted methodology, assumptions, and interpretations are appropriate to the structure and the problem being addressed.

Particular attention is given to identifying governing mechanisms, sources of uncertainty, and potential consequences of simplifying assumptions. Where necessary, alternative interpretations or checks are developed to clarify critical issues.

In peer review assignments, our role is advisory rather than prescriptive. We do not replace the engineer of record, nor do we assume responsibility for design decisions. Instead, we provide objective technical feedback intended to support robust engineering outcomes.

Our reviews are documented clearly and transparently, allowing project stakeholders to understand both the basis of the review and the implications of the findings.

Call to Action